S07: Self‑strengthening and its limits

History of China Since 1800

January 21, 2026

Class Schedule

Time Group 1 Group 2
11:30-11:45 Lecture Lecture
11:45-12:10 Objects learning Discussion
12:10-12:35 Discussion Objects learning

Lecture

Anthem of the Beyang Fleet

Qing on the verge

Mid-19th century internal and external conflicts in Qing China

Recap: Qing in crisis

Map of Rebellions
  • Domestic unrest: Taiping, Nian, Panthay, Jakub Beg rebellions (1850s-1870s)
  • Natural disasters: Yellow River changed course (1855)
  • Succession crisis: Tongzhi (b. 1856-1875), aged 5
  • Foreign conflicts: Second Opium War; Outer Manchuria ceded to Russia

Key questions

Tangshan-Xugezhuang Railway
  • How to reform China?
  • What is this China that needs reform?
  • How did China see the West? How did the West see China?

Saving Qing

Charles George Gordon
  • Foreign mercenaries
  • Local militia
  • Regional strongmen

Rise of Regional Elites and Their New Armies

Zeng Guofan: Hunan Army

Li Hongzhang: Anhui Army

Zuo Zongtang: Campaign against Nian and in Xinjiang

Hu Linyi: Hubei Army

Rise of regional elites

  • End of “law of avoidance”, which prevented officials from serving in their home provinces to reduce corruption and favoritism.
  • Regional armies, personally loyal to their commanders than to the empire
  • Rise of local gentry and elite-led militia across the empire

Conservative Modernizers

Zeng Guofan, Governor-general of Liangjiang, Founder of Hunan Army (1811-1872)
  • Loyalty to Qing
  • Belief in Confucian ethics and moral self-cultivation
  • Western technology in defense of Confucian statesmanship

Self-strengthening: Main Areas

Jinling Arsenal Assembly Cannons
  • Decentralization: Power devolution from the imperial center
  • Militarization: “Prosperous state and strong military”
  • Modernization: Of administration and diplomacy
  • Westernization: Of education, culture, and values

Changing economic landscape

Shanghai Garden Bridge, 1887
  • Traditional economic centers decimated by civil war and internal migration
  • Depressed agricultural yield; labor more expensive than land
  • Shift of domestic trade from hinterland to coast
  • Treaty ports as centers of commercial boom and self-strengthening initiatives

Post-Taiping fiscal reforms

Sir Robert Hart (1835-1911): Inspector-General of the Chinese Maritime Customs Service

New gov revenue:

  • Commercial transit tax
  • Imperial Maritime Customs

But limited impact:

  • Decline of land tax
  • Most new revenue from domestic and int’l trade to foreign gov and local elites
  • Limited improvement to chronic budget deficits

Catch-up industrialization

Jiangnan Arsenal

Shanghai Merchants Steam Navigation Company

“Official supervision, merchant management”

Sheng Xuanhuai(1844-1916), key shareholder of China Merchants’ Steam Navigation Company; Imperial Telegraph Administration’ Hanyang Iron Works; Huasheng Spinning and Weaving Company
  • Western-style, capital-intensive enterprises
  • Accompanied by new naval academies and educational facilities
  • Management shared between gov and merchants
  • Capital raised through selling shares or gov loans
  • Rise of hybrid “gentry-merchant”: combining moral rectitude with commercial development

State capitalism

Hanyang Steel Works
  • Gov ties as both asset and liability: Vulnerable to state extraction and intervention
  • Obscure lines of decision and responsibility
  • Enterprises as bases of political patronage, local loyalties, and corruption

“Prosperous state and strong military”

Huai army

Huai army artillery drill

Joining the “comity of nations”

Zongli yamen, founded in 1861

Group portrait of diplomats from China with Minister Anson Burlingame and others (1868), China’s first embassy to the United States

Chinese Educational Mission

In 1854, Yung Wing (容闳, 1828–1912) became the first Chinese student to graduate from a North American university.
  • The Chinese Educational Mission was established in the late 19th century to send Chinese students to the United States for education.
  • It aimed to modernize China’s education system and promote Western knowledge and skills.
  • Over 120 students were sent to study various subjects, including science and engineering.

Chinese Educational Mission, continued

Chinese Education Mission: First group of Chinese boys departing for Hartford, 1872

The “Orientals” Baseball Club at the Chinese Educational Mission (中國留美幼童 Zhongguo liumei you tong) Headquarters, Hartford, Connecticut, 1878. Thomas La Fargue Papers, Washington State University Libraries’ Manuscripts, Archives, and Special Collections (MASC).

New-style education at home

Private school

Peiyang University, today Tianjin University

Room A

Debate: Essence vs. Function

Zhang Zhidong (1837-1909)

How to reform Chinese statecraft?

Feng Guifen (1809-1874)

“When methods are faulty, we should reject them even though they are of ancient origins; when methods are good, we should benefit from them even though they are those of the barbarians.”

How to reform Chinese statecraft? Continued

Opening of Wusong Railway
  • Western superiority came not only from military, but from four institutions: education, government, and science
  • Affinity between Chinese tradition of local autonomy and Western representative democracy
  • Two-level administration: Hereditary magistrate, and elected subordinate headmen

Seeking modernity in tradition

St Joseph Church in Beijing
  • Departure from traditional Confucian statecraft: Minimal state finance, maximal popular livelihoods
  • New view of the state: Pursuit of “wealth and power”
  • At the same time, confucian tradition as resource for present issues
  • Philological scholarship as statecraft solution: “Seek truth from facts”
  • Restoring Confucianism vs. Pursuing robust reform

Life of Charles Tenney

Charles Daniel Tenney (1857-1930)
Year Life event
1857 Born in Boston, MA
1878 Dartmouth College BA
1886 Tutor to sons of Li Hongzhang
1895 First president of Beiyang University, first modern university in China
1900-1902 Secretary of Tianjin Provisional Government
1906-1908 Director of Chinese Government students in the US
1908-1920 US Legation in Beijing: Consul, Secretary, Chargé d’Affaires
1920 Return to the US
1930 Death in Palo Alto, CA

Discuss: Charles Tenney on Li Hongzhang

Charles Daniel Tenney (1857-1930)

Li Hongzhang

A Hybrid Era

19th-century China was challenged by internal uprisings, foreign invasions and radical new political ideas:

  • By the 1850s, China’s population reached 450 million.
  • 90% living a subsistence lifestyle amid conflicts and natural disasters.
  • Average life expectancy being only 40 years.
  • They lived through uncertain times: famines, rebellions, invasions, dynastic and community disintegration.

But it was also an era of extraordinary cultural creativity, and of political, social and technological innovation:

  • New cities, like Shanghai, emerged as displaced people sought safety, work, and food.
  • A rising class of entrepreneurs used new technologies and materials, sometimes taking on state roles.
  • Handicrafts became industrialized and commercialized for new markets.
  • Inventions like electricity and a new postal system changed communication and work.
  • Printed media and translated foreign books facilitated a two-way exchange of ideas.

Room B

Looking at Photographs

Describe

  • What do you see?
  • What people or objects in the photograph attracted your attention?
  • What do you notice about the arrangement of people and objects in the photograph?

Analyze

  • Who do you think the people in the photograph are?
  • What is the context of this photograph? Is it staged?
  • Who might be left out of the image?

Interpret

  • What might the purpose of the photograph be?
  • What message, if any, is the photographer trying to send?
  • Why were these particular people chosen to be in the photograph?

Inquire

  • What was happening in China at the time this photograph was taken?
  • How does the photograph fit into the context of unfolding events at the time?

Banyan Robe

Ancestor Portraits

Ancestor Group Portrait, 1796–1820, Hanging scroll; ink and color on paper, 278.2 x 112.2 cm, Cleveland Museum of Art
  • Traditional ancestor portraits were created for families to honor and remember deceased members.
  • Portraits are usually displayed on home altars during family ceremonies, like Lunar New Year, with offerings such as food, fruit, incense, and symbolic items placed before them.
  • While faces were painted for likeness, the settings were often stylized, as the ancestor was meant to appear present not physically, but spiritually and symbolically.

Ancestor Portraits: An Example

Curate an Exhibition

Choose three key objects for the following shows. What would you pick, and why?

National Museum of China

“The Road to Rejuvenation” is a permanent exhibition showcasing the explorations made by the Chinese people from all walks of life who, after being reduced to a semi-colonial, semi-feudal society since the Opium War of 1840, rose in resistance against humiliation and misery, and tried in every way possible to rejuvenate the nation.

British Museum: China’s hidden century

In a global first, the resilience and innovation of 19th-century China was revealed in a major exhibition. […] This period of violence and turmoil was also one of extraordinary creativity, driven by political, cultural and technological change. In the shadow of these events lie stories of remarkable individuals – at court, in armies, in booming cosmopolitan cities and on the global stage.

Your show

Design your own theme: What is missing in public understanding of late imperial China? How will you tell the story?